Positioning for 4 and 5-star hotels

Why should guests chooseyour hotel?

The more services you add, the more you look like the hotel next door. Location, service, rooms: it’s the answer everyone gives. And when the answers are the same, guests choose with the only thing left to compare: price.

The positioning read: free, done by hand by me, up to 6 a month. Only 4 and 5-star hotels and resorts.

The results

Direction first. Then the investment.

A renovation without a direction makes you the most beautiful hotel in the area, and beauty can be copied. With a direction, it makes you the one guests recognise.

The spa pool at Silva Splendid, Fiuggi
Silva Splendid · Fiuggi
The garden at Veridia Resort, with the Chia tower and the sea behind
Veridia Resort · Chia
A room at Tocq Hotel, Milan
Tocq Hotel · Milan
Silva Splendid, Fiuggi€7M

Annual revenue, up from €5.6M in five years. From “4-star hotel with SPA” to “The Wellness Hotel of Fiuggi”.1

Silva Splendid, Fiuggi×2

Average rate, roughly. With a narrower target, not a wider one.

Veridia Resort, Chia>60%

Direct sales. Not one of a hundred seaside resorts: the nature resort of Chia.

Silva Splendid, Fiuggi5.8%

The cost of each direct guest. Booking charges 15%.

Tocq Hotel, Milan7%

The acquisition cost of a city hotel that lives on corporate business and events.

1 The result of positioning and renovation together: positioning set the direction, the owners’ investment made it credible. The full cases ›

Positions taken

What is your hotel number one for, in your area?

The hotels that fill up without discounting aren’t always the most beautiful. They’re the ones guests can explain, in one sentence, why they chose.

Taken

The hotel you reach by train, no car needed

Shuttle from the station, bikes in the garage, dinner two hundred metres away.

Taken

The resort where children have dinner at 7 pm with the staff

And parents at 9 pm, on their own. Every review mentions it.

Taken

The city five-star where the concierge finds the table nobody can get

People coming for an opera or an exhibition have booked there for years.

Taken

The boutique hotel where breakfast runs until 1 pm

It chose the guest who doesn’t set an alarm on holiday.

Taken

The mountain hotel where you take your skis off at the door

Heated ski room, instructor in the lobby at 8.30, ski back to the hotel.

Taken

The business hotel with 6 pm check-out on Fridays

If your last meeting is in the afternoon, there’s nothing else like it. These guests have booked there for years.

Open

Yours, if you take it before the others do.

In your area there is almost always an open spot: a type of guest, a month of the year, a service nobody has put first. The positioning read tells you where to look for it.

Request the free positioning read →

Examples to explain the method, not real hotels. If you need more than three seconds to answer, that’s where the positioning read starts.

What positioning does

Staying in the crowd feels safe. It’s the most expensive position.

  1. TodayYour hotel sits among hotels that look alike. Guests compare them on price.
  2. The open positionIn almost every area there is a reason to choose that nobody owns.
  3. PositionedGuests recognise your hotel and choose it for that reason, not for the rate.
Positioning map Many similar hotels are grouped in the middle of the map, where guests compare them on price. Your hotel leaves the group and reaches an open position, easier to recognise. Recognisable to guests ↑ Average price → Generic The cheapest The historic five-star The family resort “Welcoming” · “A stone’s throw from the sea” · “Comfortable” Open position Your hotel
Example. In the full analysis I build the map around your hotel and your real competitors.
The market

The middle of the market looks like the safest place. It’s the one emptying out.

Lean, no-frills formats are growing, and so are hotels with a clear identity. The middle is shrinking: four and five-stars that all say the same things.

Demand trend by type of property

The hotel market is polarising A U-shaped curve: demand grows at both ends, for lean formats and for boutique hotels and resorts with a strong identity, and falls in the middle, for undifferentiated hotels.
GrowingLean, no-frills formats: essential three-stars, hostels and affordable design hotels.
ShrinkingFour and five-stars that all say the same things: understated luxury, relaxation, an exclusive experience.
GrowingBoutique hotels and resorts with a strong, recognisable identity.
A qualitative sketch of the trend, not measured data.
One-minute test

How many of these phrases are on your homepage?

Open your website and those of two nearby hotels. Tap the phrases you find.

0/12

None so far. It works better with your homepage open alongside.

The problem is almost never the budget. It’s the promises. If you make the same promises as the hotel next door, to guests you are the hotel next door. Just at a different price.

What you get, free

In three days you know how a guest reads you. With the logo covered.

I cover the logos and read your homepage next to your competitors’. Then I read the reviews: where guests keep repeating the same thing, that’s usually your reason. One page, written by me. No logins, no passwords.

  1. 1

    The comparison

    The opening line of your homepage next to those of 2-3 competitors, with the logo covered.

  2. 2

    The verdict

    Positioned, replaceable or invisible. With the reasons, line by line.

  3. 3

    The clue

    Where your reason probably lies: what guests keep repeating in their reviews.

If you want to go further

The full analysis finds the reason and puts it into words.

The positioning read shows you the problem. I don’t hand out ready-made lines: a line written without reading the reviews and the competitors is just another hotel line.

The full analysis is six documents: the reason in one sentence, the guest who believes in it, the words ready for your homepage, Booking and the phone, how to sell without discounting, what to change in the hotel itself, and the first 90 days already written. Delivered in English.

With a guarantee: if it doesn’t convince you, I refund everything. And I give you another €500.

How the analysis works →
Free Done by hand Up to 6 a month 40 rooms or more Within 3 working days
Francesco Astolfi
Who does it

Francesco Astolfi. Twenty years in hotels, from every side.

I took TUI.it from zero to thirty million. I led marketing at Atahotels. I worked in an agency for hotels and opened ten venues with my own capital. I do every positioning read and every analysis myself, by hand. That’s why there are at most six free positioning reads a month.

Consultants sell advice. Operators sell scars.
My story Francesco Astolfi
A fair question

Why it’s free.

Because the positioning read shows you the problem, not the solution. It’s how I introduce myself: instead of telling you how I work, I show you on your own homepage.

If the verdict convinces you, the solution is the full analysis. If not, you keep the page, and that’s fine.

No surprise quotes, no chasing. If you want to go further, you tell me.
How it works

Three steps. The first takes a minute.

1
One minute

Request the positioning read

Your hotel, website and two or three competitors.

2
Within 3 working days

Receive the positioning read

One page: the comparison, the verdict, the clue on where to look for your reason.

3
Your call

The full analysis, or you keep the page

If you want, I find your reason and put it into words, with the guarantee. You decide if and when. Otherwise the page is yours to keep.

Who it’s for

Let’s be clear. It isn’t for everyone.

It’s for you if

  • You run an independent 4 or 5-star hotel or resort.
  • You want a rate that holds without discounts, even off season.
  • You’re ready to change words, offers and priorities, if needed.

It isn’t for you if

  • You think the only problem is Booking, and the fix is a lower rate on your website.
  • You hope a new website or a renovation will be enough on their own.
  • You want more followers, not more direct bookings.

I’m telling you upfront, so neither of us wastes time.

Questions

The questions everyone asks me.

How much does it cost?

The positioning read costs nothing: no contract, no paid second part to read the verdict. If you want to go further, the full analysis has a clear price, €697 + VAT, and a guarantee: if it doesn’t convince you, I refund everything and give you another €500.

Why don’t you just give me a new line straight away?

Because a line written without reading the reviews and the competitors is just another hotel line. First you find the reason: that’s the job of the full analysis.

Do you need access to the PMS, the booking engine or Analytics?

No. I work on what guests see: your website, your competitors’ websites, the reviews.

How much of my time does it take?

One minute for the request. I do the rest: you receive the positioning read within 3 working days.

Why only 6 a month?

Because I do them myself, by hand, site by site. More than that, done properly, isn’t possible.

What if my hotel is a three-star?

The positioning read is designed for 4 and 5-star hotels and resorts. For other properties there’s the book, the positioning test and the free tools.

Does it work for a boutique hotel with few rooms?

Yes, if it’s a 4 or 5-star. What counts is the level, not the number of rooms.

Does it work for a city hotel that lives on corporate business and events?

Yes. At Tocq Hotel in Milan the acquisition cost is 7%.

Do you work in English?

Yes. I deliver the read and the analysis in English too, for international owners and management.

What if I don’t want to go any further?

The page is yours to keep. I won’t chase you: if you want the full analysis, you tell me.

Free positioning read

Request the positioning read of your homepage.

Three answers about your hotel, on one page.

  1. 01How your opening line sounds next to your competitors’, with the logo covered.
  2. 02The verdict: positioned, replaceable or invisible.
  3. 03Where to look for the reason guests should choose you.

Done by hand by Francesco Astolfi. No contract, no commitment.

Up to 6 a month. Only 4 and 5-star hotels and resorts. You receive it within 3 working days, in English.

Positioning read0%
Write your name and role, so I know who to reply to.
Write the name of the hotel.
Write the website address.
Check the address: the positioning read arrives here.
Choose your hotel’s category.
Write at least one competitor: the read is a comparison.

Free · no commitment · you get it within 3 working days.
Up to 6 a month, only 4 and 5-star hotels and resorts. Delivered in English.

✓

Request received.

I've received the request for your hotel: I'll write to you within 3 working days. In the meantime, try this: cover the logo on your homepage and on a competitor's, and read the first two sentences. If they can be swapped, that's where the positioning read starts.

Request the free positioning read →