The problem · Too much OTA commission

Rely less on the OTAs.

OTA commission takes a bigger bite out of your margin every year. For an 80-room hotel it comes to about €150,000 a year.

Booking.com brings bookings, but the guest stays theirs. The cause is rarely the channel: the guest can't find a reason to book with you.

The positioning read: free, and done by hand, by me. Up to 6 a month, in English, delivered within 3 working days.

A worked exampleExample
  • An 80-room hotel× 80
  • Bookings that come through Booking.com× 60%
  • Commission× 18%
Annual commission€150,000

With an average rate of €95 and 50% occupancy. Over ten years, about €1.5 million.

N°01

Booking.com is a channel. It shouldn't be the channel.

The goal isn't to leave Booking. It's to know what it costs you, and to cut its share where you can.

Booking brings bookings. It doesn't bring you guests of your own.

The email address, the relationship and the next booking stay with the portal. You fill the rooms; Booking builds its brand.

Past half of your bookings, it's no longer a channel. It's a dependency.

It shrinks when guests search for your hotel by name. And they search for it when they know why to choose it.

The cost of commissionWith your numbers
Annual commission to Booking €149,796

Over ten years, about one and a half million.

Example values: 80 rooms, €95 a night, 50% occupancy. Enter yours: the calculation stays in your browser.

N°02

Ten signs of OTA dependency.

Select the ones you recognise in your hotel.

01

The answer to “Why you?”

A guest asks: “What makes you different?” You answer: “Care, quality, attention.” They thank you and book another hotel on Booking.

If the answer doesn't fit in thirty seconds, it isn't clear yet.

02

No filter on enquiries.

You accept every booking. Then you notice that guests don't understand what you offer.

Being specific means choosing. And choosing means leaving some guests out.

03

Booking is your first channel.

It brings 60 bookings in every 100 and keeps 18%. With 80 rooms, that's about €150,000 a year.

Beyond a certain share, it's no longer a channel: it's a dependency.

04

Free upgrades in low season.

The room was empty, the upgrade costs nothing. But guests learn to wait for a deal, even in July.

A discount, repeated, teaches guests not to pay full price.

05

Rates unchanged for years.

You're afraid of losing bookings. A rise mostly loses you the guests least suited to your hotel.

Low rates attract guests who choose on price.

06

A website that lists services.

“4-star hotel. Spa. Restaurant. Relaxation.” With another logo, it would fit a hundred hotels.

Among a hundred similar hotels, guests pick the cheapest.

07

Campaigns that return little.

€2,000 of ads, 50 clicks, 2 bookings. Anyone clicks; the guests who book are the ones who understood what you offer.

Advertising amplifies the message. Even when it's generic.

08

Interchangeable reviews.

“Clean. Friendly. Good value for money.” What's missing is the one that says: “The only place where I found…”

Reviews reflect your positioning. If it's generic, so are they.

09

The seasonal seesaw.

Discounts and promotions in low season, full in high season. Then the cycle starts again.

You react to the season instead of building demand of your own. That's the ground where the OTAs win.

10

The guests lost after a rate rise.

You raise the rate and the guests who only look at price go elsewhere. It feels like a loss.

Often it's a filter: the room goes to the guests who see its value.

N°03

Commission is a sign. The cause sits further back.

There are three steps between your hotel and your revenue. Booking works on the last one. So do almost all direct-booking fixes.

Step one

Positioning

Who you are, and for which guest.

Step two

Promise

What you tell the guest, and where.

Step three

Booking

What you take in, and how much goes to Booking.

A new booking engine, direct-booking campaigns, a better rate on your website: all step three. Useful, but it comes later.

Guests book direct when they have a reason to search for you by name. That reason is decided in step one. It's called positioning.

Booking puts you in a list. An AI assistant makes a choice.Francesco Astolfi

The method in six steps →
N°04

First the compass. Then the walls.

Case · Silva Splendid · Fiuggi

From “4-star hotel with spa” to The Wellness Hotel of Fiuggi.

  1. 118 rooms and the largest spa in Lazio. Yet it spoke to everyone, and nobody remembered it.
  2. The choice: a fact instead of an adjective, a category with the definite article (in Italian, L’Hotel Benessere di Fiuggi), and almost no families any more.
  3. In five years, revenue goes from €5.6 million to €7 million. The average rate roughly doubles.
Annual revenue €5.6M €7M

Positioning and renovation together: the first set the direction, the owners' investment made it credible. In that order.

For direct sales, the case is a different one. Veridia Resort, the nature resort of Chia, sells over 60% direct. I don't have a before-and-after revenue comparison, so I don't present one.

N°05

First the teardown. Then, if needed, the analysis.

Before you touch the website and the campaigns, you need to know what to tell guests so they book with you.

Positioning read · up to 6 a month

Free

I do it myself, by hand. Only 4 and 5-star hotels and resorts.

  • The first line of your homepage next to those of 2-3 competitors, with the logos covered.
  • A verdict: positioned, replaceable or invisible.
  • A clue to where your reason lies, taken from your reviews.
  • One page, in English, within 3 working days. No commitment.
Request the free positioning read →

Full analysis · after the positioning read

€697+ VAT

Your reason, found and put in writing, with what you need to use it.

  • 6 documents: the reason, who believes it, the words, how to sell without selling yourself short, what to change in-house, the first 90 days.
  • Delivered in English, 2 days after the questionnaire.
  • Guarantee: if it doesn't convince you, I refund everything. And I give you another €500.
How it works →

All the details of the full analysis →The six documents, the guarantee, how I work.

Free · up to 6 a month

Request the positioning read.

One minute. All I need is your hotel, its website and 2-3 competitors. I read your first line the way a guest does who has just closed Booking.com.

  • One page: your first line next to those of 2-3 competitors, logos covered. A verdict, and a clue to where your reason lies.
  • Independent 4 and 5-star hotels and resorts.
  • You get it by email, in English, within 3 working days. No commitment.
  • No ready-made lines or alternatives: those are the work of the full analysis.
  • Not for you if you want instant results, or think positioning is a matter of copywriting.
Positioning read0%
Write your name and role, so I know who to reply to.
Write the name of the hotel.
Write the website address.
Check the address: the positioning read arrives here.
Choose your hotel’s category.
Write at least one competitor: the read is a comparison.

Free · no commitment · you get it within 3 working days.
Up to 6 a month, only 4 and 5-star hotels and resorts. Delivered in English.

✓

Request received.

I've received the request for your hotel: I'll write to you within 3 working days. In the meantime, try this: cover the logo on your homepage and on a competitor's, and read the first two sentences. If they can be swapped, that's where the positioning read starts.

FAQ

The questions I'm asked most often.

Do I have to leave Booking?

No. Booking stays a channel, but stops being the main one. When guests search for your hotel by name, direct bookings grow. The work is giving them a reason to do it.

Do I need a new website?

No. You change the headline, the introduction and the key copy. A new site comes later, and only if needed.

Does it work for a smaller hotel too?

Yes, often better. A 40-room hotel can choose a precise niche; a 200-room hotel has to hold several segments together.

What do AI assistants have to do with commission?

Booking shows a hundred hotels. An AI assistant recommends two or three: the ones that are recognisable, specific and consistent on every channel. It can only describe well what is already clear.

Request the free positioning read →